Hundreds of car hailing vehicles parked for days at HDB carpark, no demand why hoard cars, high COE ?

[Busker888]

Maybe AMOT Chee can comment on this ? No drivers demand, PHVs parked for days...time to look into efficient use of vehicles rather than hoarding of cars by rail hailing companies.

[shinkong]

LTA should implement minimum mileage for PHV

[Mockngbrd]

y wld MOT give. shit? 

[Gnahp]

I won't complain

a parked vehicle contributes zero emission, zero contribution to the traffic congestion and pay full taxes

[L23]

On 1/3/2024 at 12:55 PM, Gnahp said:

I won't complain

a parked vehicle contributes zero emission, zero contribution to the traffic congestion and pay full taxes

yr calculation sala la.

The govt is losing big when the car do not move:

1. Petrol tax

2. ERP

3. Tax on those carpark facilty

4. Tax on those company doing maintenance - More car usage = more servicing require + more breakdown

There are more in the equation if u think deeper...

 

 

By the way, which govt really care about zero emission and zero contribution to the traffic congestion??

zero emission - What happen to Tesla and all EV car in SG?

zero contribution to the traffic congestion - Complain more, We simply up the ERP. Remember ERP is to ease the traffic?

Edited January 3, 2024 by L23

[Fcw75]

But Amy Khor said no proof that PHV companies are pushing up COE prices wor.

Don’t even know if they are paying for season parking or not.

Once they need one of these cars, they just ask a tow truck to tow it out without paying for any parking charge.

I have seen this happened at my estate carpark and it’s done by used car dealers.

Normally they are the same type of people.

Edited January 3, 2024 by Fcw75

[ER-3682]

On 1/3/2024 at 11:50 AM, Busker888 said:

Maybe AMOT Chee can comment on this ? No drivers demand, PHVs parked for days...time to look into efficient use of vehicles rather than hoarding of cars by rail hailing companies.

This Carpark look like in Bishan Area.

[Gnahp]

On 1/3/2024 at 1:22 PM, L23 said:

yr calculation sala la.

The govt is losing big when the car do not move:

1. Petrol tax

2. ERP

3. Tax on those carpark facilty

4. Tax on those company doing maintenance - More car usage = more servicing require + more breakdown

There are more in the equation if u think deeper...

 

 

By the way, which govt really care about zero emission and zero contribution to the traffic congestion??

zero emission - What happen to Tesla and all EV car in SG?

zero contribution to the traffic congestion - Complain more, We simply up the ERP. Remember ERP is to ease the traffic?

it is in line with the car-lite ideology that they are promoting 😁

 

 

[Busker888]

@ER-3682 yup. sharp eyes, apparently it is the MCP beside Cath High

[Busker888]

On 1/3/2024 at 1:22 PM, L23 said:

yr calculation sala la.

The govt is losing big when the car do not move:

1. Petrol tax

2. ERP

3. Tax on those carpark facilty

4. Tax on those company doing maintenance - More car usage = more servicing require + more breakdown

There are more in the equation if u think deeper...

 

 

By the way, which govt really care about zero emission and zero contribution to the traffic congestion??

zero emission - What happen to Tesla and all EV car in SG?

zero contribution to the traffic congestion - Complain more, We simply up the ERP. Remember ERP is to ease the traffic?

Yeah...all these green bs are to seek those ignorant "green" proponents votes....diversity, whatever BS rights voters. Green talks are for the rich and ignorants..

[Beehive3783]

On 1/3/2024 at 11:50 AM, Busker888 said:

Maybe AMOT Chee can comment on this ? No drivers demand, PHVs parked for days...time to look into efficient use of vehicles rather than hoarding of cars by rail hailing companies.

Let the leasing companies die peacefully la... 

[Inlinefour]

no wonder that carpark always full one 🙈🙉🙊

[Kb27]

These PHV cars are owned by rental companies. When there's not enough demand, they need a place to park them.

These would be seasonal parking arranged with the car park owners, at more ulu area where parking lots are in excess.

[kobayashiGT]

one photo doesn't proof anything. need to do study, need to monitor. need a lot of resources. a lot of scholars. alot of money. 😂

[Watwheels]

Dont waste your breath to try and talk logic with LTA. They collect money wan, chap siao the rest.

Simi emission, simi congestion, simi high coe price, they just sit around collect money. Only we the cum gong kia kan cheong over all these issues.

[Stary]

On 1/3/2024 at 12:55 PM, Gnahp said:

I won't complain

a parked vehicle contributes zero emission, zero contribution to the traffic congestion and pay full taxes

I will complain

The opportunity cost during the "parking period" will surely be pass back to consumers through higher fees in the future.

Any increase in transportation fees, be it consumer or commercial,  will surely escalate into price inflation on goods and services'.

In addition, cars that don't move will mean less revenue to the authorities (less petrol, less erp, etc)

And guess where the revenue loss has to be covered back from? 

😥

Edited January 3, 2024 by Starry

[Benarsenal]

CCB PAP

[Arogab]

This will make them slowly go down the drain. Is ok