mcs08 1st Gear January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 Will like advice from fellow car enthusiasts for advice on the 3 cars: Which will you put your money in and why? (Thanks for giving me your reason!) I am aware that the 3 of them belong to different categories but their prices are pretty similar and imho, they all look good and each one with their individual ups & downs. WHICH is WHY I am caught in a dilemma in which to get. I had also test driven them, except the CLA250(not available for test drive) and am loving how the Jag handles and how wonderful the pull of the BMW is. Test driven the CLA180SB, underpowered and am not a fan of FWD, especially so for wagon driving. For my needs, it's basically a 4-5door family-type of car with a fun aspect, definitely. Not too shabby a price when I sell in 3-4years time. Jaguar XE CLA 250 Shooting Brake BMW 330i, F30 Thanks in advance for all your helpful inputs! ↡ Advertisement Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ttl1976 5th Gear January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 I chose jag purely for the look. If i m in your position, i go with my heart. Whichever sings to you. Congrats in advance 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcs08 1st Gear January 6, 2016 Author Share January 6, 2016 I chose jag purely for the look. If i m in your position, i go with my heart. Whichever sings to you. Congrats in advance My heart is currently split 3 ways! Lol! Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Weez911 Supersonic January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 Hard to recommend because I have not driven all 3 cars as owner. Some brothers may have driven the 328i and the CLA, maybe they can chip in? Anyway from reports they seems to be fantastic cars. Happy choosing and I'm sure any of these will turn out well! Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Steptronic Supercharged January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 BMW to drive, MB to be driven in, Jag is well no comments! 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thaiyotakamli Supersonic January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 BMW to drive, MB to be driven in, Jag is well no comments! To be driven? I rather sit in 3 series than CLA back cramp seat lol Back to topic, i think XE would be my choice since its new model and most chio. For power and driving i will choose F30 And i will avoid CLA 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcs08 1st Gear January 6, 2016 Author Share January 6, 2016 Hard to recommend because I have not driven all 3 cars as owner. Some brothers may have driven the 328i and the CLA, maybe they can chip in? Anyway from reports they seems to be fantastic cars. Happy choosing and I'm sure any of these will turn out well! Exactly why i'm not sure which one to take to the highway with! Kind of miss the days when choosing was easy ...or maybe it never was? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
edwin15 4th Gear January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 The 330 is same price as the other 2? I thought it would be more expensive. As for CLA250 SB, why not consider C200 instead. Around same price but better I think. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Klloh28 Clutched January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 I test drive xe. Love the car and power but do you realise the rear and boot space is really small? I might be considering to get a audi a6, huge rear space. 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcs08 1st Gear January 6, 2016 Author Share January 6, 2016 The 330 is same price as the other 2? I thought it would be more expensive. As for CLA250 SB, why not consider C200 instead. Around same price but better I think. Bro, not same price la! Around the same price as I'm adding in options here and there. Basically, the price from lowest to highest is CLA250SB, 330i, XE. C200 is not in my consideration..as i don't really like how the new c-class looks. I do have a 2012 W204 and, no offense to anybody, but I will choose it over the W205 any day. 3 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
edwin15 4th Gear January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 Bro, not same price la! Around the same price as I'm adding in options here and there. Basically, the price from lowest to highest is CLA250SB, 330i, XE. C200 is not in my consideration..as i don't really like how the new c-class looks. I do have a 2012 W204 and, no offense to anybody, but I will choose it over the W205 any day. How much is the 330 going for? I know the XE is 195k. Thought 330 is around 220 to 230? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcs08 1st Gear January 6, 2016 Author Share January 6, 2016 I test drive xe. Love the car and power but do you realise the rear and boot space is really small? I might be considering to get a audi a6, huge rear space. Yea, I love the power of the XE initially till I test drove the 330i....! In the end, I love the steering accuracy and ride stability of the XE & love the power and exhaust note of the 330i. Is like, should I go with the power/exhaust audio or steering/suspension setup? Apart from the boot being small, not too much of an issue to me, the exhaust note is pretty much inaudible and also hidden. Something that I am not quite used to. - I'm used to driving cars with mods Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
EXO 4th Gear January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 Maybe he looking at the V6 Supercharged model How much is the 330 going for? I know the XE is 195k. Thought 330 is around 220 to 230? 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
edwin15 4th Gear January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 Maybe he looking at the V6 Supercharged model Like this then the XE V6 will be my choice. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcs08 1st Gear January 6, 2016 Author Share January 6, 2016 Maybe he looking at the V6 Supercharged model V6? Not even thinking about it! Definitely in excess of 280! It's a pity the 237hp model is not coming in though. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blueray Hypersonic January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 Between the 3, XE. But XE price years down the road probably the weakest ? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcs08 1st Gear January 6, 2016 Author Share January 6, 2016 Between the 3, XE. But XE price years down the road probably the weakest ? I think the BMW should have the best resale value, follow by CLA/XE. But it being a LCI model...? Between the shooting brake and XE, i am not sure which one will be better or worse. Or maybe it'll be a 3-way tie? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blueray Hypersonic January 6, 2016 Share January 6, 2016 I think the BMW should have the best resale value, follow by CLA/XE. But it being a LCI model...? Between the shooting brake and XE, i am not sure which one will be better or worse. Or maybe it'll be a 3-way tie? buy another W204. got some 2014 and 2013 ones on sgcarmart. ↡ Advertisement 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In NowRelated Discussions
Related Discussions
[Spyshots] 2026 2nd Generation Mercedes Benz GLB
[Spyshots] 2026 2nd Generation Mercedes Benz GLB
All BMW owner thread
All BMW owner thread
My EV journey to the i4
My EV journey to the i4
Jaguar's Next Chapter, A Calculated or Suicidal Move?
Jaguar's Next Chapter, A Calculated or Suicidal Move?
2025 BMW X3 G45
2025 BMW X3 G45
MSCP Self-Service Car Wash Hoggers
MSCP Self-Service Car Wash Hoggers
2019 Mercedes-Benz GLB-Class (X247)
2019 Mercedes-Benz GLB-Class (X247)