Shawntcl 1st Gear March 30, 2016 Share March 30, 2016 Correct me if i`m wrong... Carens : Petrol 2.0L variant using conventional 6 speeder GB, Diesel 1.7L variant using DCT 7 speeder. Yes, only diesel version using DCT. One of the main attraction for me is the torque that the diesel engine brings, also the skyroof, bigger rim etc, that only the SX variant have. Correct me if i`m wrong... Carens : Petrol 2.0L variant using conventional 6 speeder GB, Diesel 1.7L variant using DCT 7 speeder. Yes, only diesel version using DCT. One of the main attraction for me is the torque that the diesel engine brings, also the skyroof, bigger rim etc, that only the SX variant have. ↡ Advertisement Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Valrosx 3rd Gear March 30, 2016 Share March 30, 2016 Yes, only diesel version using DCT. One of the main attraction for me is the torque that the diesel engine brings, also the skyroof, bigger rim etc, that only the SX variant have. Yes, only diesel version using DCT. One of the main attraction for me is the torque that the diesel engine brings, also the skyroof, bigger rim etc, that only the SX variant have. Thanks for clarifying. For someone like me who travels less than 15000km per year, guess my pick would be the petrol variant, as i can't justify paying the higher road tax and $10k difference between SX Diesel and petrol. Wonder what is the servicing costs for a Diesel..think CnC gives 3 years free servicing? Going to the showroom to look see soon, my COE expires this Oct... Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blackyv Turbocharged March 30, 2016 Share March 30, 2016 My take is simple, dual clutch needs a few more years to mature before it can reach auto gb kind of realibility .. Imagine even Honda can have multiple recall on their hybrid vezel due to dual clutch gb, I won't dare to touch it just yet for sure... 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
teomingern 6th Gear March 31, 2016 Share March 31, 2016 My take is simple, dual clutch needs a few more years to mature before it can reach auto gb kind of realibility .. Imagine even Honda can have multiple recall on their hybrid vezel due to dual clutch gb, I won't dare to touch it just yet for sure... Agree... not say cannot touch but don't expect it to be as refined as the normal auto gearbox. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Forte3737 5th Gear March 31, 2016 Share March 31, 2016 Cvt not bad. They can consider using it Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apple-Tree 6th Gear April 2, 2016 Share April 2, 2016 If petrol Carens is OK, then you are probably in the buying season as they are adv. hard to sell off its YOM 15 stock. Someone here mentioned the petrol version will be discontinued after that. Not sure., There is probably a future issue with petrol car, with such a low cost crude, we generally did not enjoy much saving due to the increase in Petrol duty in FY2015. With O&G bankruptcy at high not seen after 2009, a new known issue arise. A recently report states that investment to replenish spent oil well is at 75%. That means for every 100 old well shut, there is 75 new well replacement. The current supply glut should be over by 2018. Then as the usual history repeat, a oil shock will come. Again, it is just a possible risk. And current there are only about 6K diesel car on the road. As for me, I probably go try out the Mazda 5 too, compression ratio 14:1, 2L and a non-DCT GB. Thanks for clarifying.For someone like me who travels less than 15000km per year, guess my pick would be the petrol variant, as i can't justify paying the higher road tax and $10k difference between SX Diesel and petrol.Wonder what is the servicing costs for a Diesel..think CnC gives 3 years free servicing?Going to the showroom to look see soon, my COE expires this Oct... Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
teomingern 6th Gear April 3, 2016 Share April 3, 2016 If petrol Carens is OK, then you are probably in the buying season as they are adv. hard to sell off its YOM 15 stock. Someone here mentioned the petrol version will be discontinued after that. Not sure., There is probably a future issue with petrol car, with such a low cost crude, we generally did not enjoy much saving due to the increase in Petrol duty in FY2015. With O&G bankruptcy at high not seen after 2009, a new known issue arise. A recently report states that investment to replenish spent oil well is at 75%. That means for every 100 old well shut, there is 75 new well replacement. The current supply glut should be over by 2018. Then as the usual history repeat, a oil shock will come. Again, it is just a possible risk. And current there are only about 6K diesel car on the road. As for me, I probably go try out the Mazda 5 too, compression ratio 14:1, 2L and a non-DCT GB. Isn't the Mazda 5 an old design? It's not the latest right like the 3, 6? Not sure... just asking. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr_biscuit 3rd Gear April 3, 2016 Share April 3, 2016 I would think that the current petrol Carens (6 Speeder) is a better buy compared to Diesel Carens which is now more expensive due to increase popularity. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apple-Tree 6th Gear April 3, 2016 Share April 3, 2016 Not sure too, but if it can sell about 100 units every month, cannot be that bad. Also not much complain on the web, it is the ultra lean GDI that attract me. Look see mode. And trying not to buy on impulse ..... heeee... Isn't the Mazda 5 an old design? It's not the latest right like the 3, 6? Not sure... just asking. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apple-Tree 6th Gear April 3, 2016 Share April 3, 2016 Based on CO2 and weight, the FC should be on the high side but better than my 191g/km Carens (UN). C&C only sold 84 KIA MPV last year. For Jan, 9P3D Carens, For Feb, 2P8D Carens. Anyway, I don't think it is a KIA issue, at least I am currently driving a Carens and did NOT need to repair GB EVERY 2 YEARS. I find KIA surprisingly OK, not much issue except ABS, Airbag, which is minor, I can even fixed it myself. Which I did. And thanks all the bro and sis here for bringing up the DCT issue. I can't afford this kind of reliability schedule lor. But internet said, KIA ownself design the DCT GB, and the 7DCT is the second design after the 6DCT ?? Not sure. As of today, no reported issue. Look see mode. Still got time ... not in the hurry to spend ... heeee I would think that the current petrol Carens (6 Speeder) is a better buy compared to Diesel Carens which is now more expensive due to increase popularity. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
teomingern 6th Gear April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 Not sure too, but if it can sell about 100 units every month, cannot be that bad. Also not much complain on the web, it is the ultra lean GDI that attract me. Look see mode. And trying not to buy on impulse ..... heeee... Totally understand the impulse thing... :) Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
ling9986 Neutral Newbie April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 Hi All So it not advisable to get the diesel version isit. Anyone have any view on the Orlando 1.4 turbo. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vwguy77 3rd Gear April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 Hi All So it not advisable to get the diesel version isit. Anyone have any view on the Orlando 1.4 turbo. I don't think that is the general sentiment. Rather, it is advisable that you take the test drive personally and have a feel for the car itself and its the same for the Orlando as well. Nothing beat trying out the car than purely reading and reading the forum itself. Once you are done with that, do factor in the diesel road tax plus the diesel fuel cost and count into your annual driving pattern to derive the annual cost of running. From there, you can probably see whether the diesel version works in your favor or not. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apple-Tree 6th Gear April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 I glad you ask, Mazda and Chevy are just next to each other. Can test-drive in 1 go. My concern are : a) How did a 1.4L car end up in CAT B b) Is the door still that heavy c) Is the tyres profile common. As a matter of facts, Kah, Borneo, C&C are there too. Give a try. Anyway, try to buy a Mercedes SLK today, was told my favourite colour is sold out. Left with Pink and Black. Stock available this Friday onwards. Hi All So it not advisable to get the diesel version isit. Anyone have any view on the Orlando 1.4 turbo. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
ling9986 Neutral Newbie April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 I don't think that is the general sentiment. Rather, it is advisable that you take the test drive personally and have a feel for the car itself and its the same for the Orlando as well. Nothing beat trying out the car than purely reading and reading the forum itself. Once you are done with that, do factor in the diesel road tax plus the diesel fuel cost and count into your annual driving pattern to derive the annual cost of running. From there, you can probably see whether the diesel version works in your favor or not. test drive both, kia diesel has a better drive but orlando has much cheaper running cost. but i was told that orlando not that reliable. i am clocking around 25000km annually thus cant decide which one. Mazda interior lack behind both this car in my view thus i did not test drive that. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vwguy77 3rd Gear April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 (edited) test drive both, kia diesel has a better drive but orlando has much cheaper running cost. but i was told that orlando not that reliable. i am clocking around 25000km annually thus cant decide which one. Mazda interior lack behind both this car in my view thus i did not test drive that. If you do drive 25,000 km per year, you will definitely benefit from driving a diesel instead of petrol car. Lets do some simple math using car maker spec (I know its debatable but good enough to some analysis) KIA Carens: - Total Fuel Required = 25000km / 19.2 km/L = 1302 liters - Total Fuel Cost = 1302 liters x S$1.07/L = $1,393 - Road Tax = $1,518 - Total Cost = $2,911 Chevy Orlando: - Total Fuel Required = 25000km / 14.1 km/L = 1,773 liters - Total Fuel Cost = 1773 liters x S$1.89/L = $3,351 - Road Tax = $604 - Total Cost = $3,955 A cool savings of $1,044 per year.... thats the calculation my brother and I ran to decide on the family car. Also, he really likes the finishing of the KIA Carens and the savings shown above seals the deal for him. Edited April 4, 2016 by Vwguy77 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
ling9986 Neutral Newbie April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 If you do drive 25,000 km per year, you will definitely benefit from driving a diesel instead of petrol car. Lets do some simple math using car maker spec (I know its debatable but good enough to some analysis) KIA Carens: - Total Fuel Required = 25000km / 19.2 km/L = 1302 liters - Total Fuel Cost = 1302 liters x S$1.07/L = $1,393 - Road Tax = $1,518 - Total Cost = $2,911 Chevy Orlando: - Total Fuel Required = 25000km / 14.1 km/L = 1,773 liters - Total Fuel Cost = 1773 liters x S$1.89/L = $3,351 - Road Tax = $604 - Total Cost = $3,955 A cool savings of $1,044 per year.... thats the calculation my brother and I ran to decide on the family car. Also, he really likes the finishing of the KIA Carens and the savings shown above seals the deal for him. but the orlando i can get it for 97K compare to caren at 109k. btw i am a miss and tks for doing the sum for me i really dun like to work out all this ;) Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Shawntcl 1st Gear April 4, 2016 Share April 4, 2016 but the orlando i can get it for 97K compare to caren at 109k. btw i am a miss and tks for doing the sum for me i really dun like to work out all this ;) Orlando is petrol or diesel? If petrol, then Carens Diesel will be paying much higher road tax per year. ↡ Advertisement Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In NowRelated Discussions
Related Discussions
Haiz...another suicide?
Haiz...another suicide?
2015 Forester 2.0
2015 Forester 2.0
KIA FY24 Carnival - Hybrid
KIA FY24 Carnival - Hybrid
Hyundai Santa Fe / Kia Sorento 2024
Hyundai Santa Fe / Kia Sorento 2024
2025 Kia K4 (Replacement of Cerato)
2025 Kia K4 (Replacement of Cerato)
2015 Mazda CX3
2015 Mazda CX3
2022 Kia EV6
2022 Kia EV6
This is the redesigned new-for-2015 KIA Sorento.
This is the redesigned new-for-2015 KIA Sorento.