Jump to content

Jaguar XF Vs C200 Vs BMW 523i


Steptronic
 Share

Which one you choose?  

186 members have voted

  1. 1. Please select one

    • Jaguar XF 3.0 Luxury
      108
    • C200 CGI
      17
    • BMW 523i 2.5
      53
    • Any other? (please specify)
      8


Recommended Posts

bro... u should compare E class with XF and not a C class...

True, but to me, E class is more of uncle's car. I would probably buy E class after few years :D

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll recommend new XF or C-class as they are just facelifted, 523i is too common on the road le.

XF looks better imo.

 

onli down side for XF would be it's road tax...

 

Why downside on road tax? Not much difference unless you are eying the diesel versions.

Link to post
Share on other sites

anyway driving an xf sure will have ppl look u have to have to like the attention if getting tt kind of vehicle

 

xf is considered super luxury

Link to post
Share on other sites

not really....the handling felt ok to me....the best thing was its automatic trans and the awesome 3 liter plus engine

 

the sales lady was nice to let me test drive for a longer time....and encouraged me to work for it and get a jaguar next time

 

test drove the vehicle at wearnes automotive

 

yes i did too there. whats her name grace is it?

 

handling felt pretty numb but didnt test thoroughly. it was the sleepy engine that i didnt like.

 

3L but feels boneless, feelingless. No growl no emotions. Doesnt feel powerful. Doesnt give a kick.

Link to post
Share on other sites

BMW is so common these days, get the Jag XF. It has a 3L V6 powerplant that tops the 2.5L straight 6 in your f10 523i. as for the Merc C class thats a step DOWN its the worst choice of the 3 in terms of whats under the hood. And it will look simply puny next to the Jag.

 

Hello friends, it is time for me to change as there is uncertainity around Mazda and COE here. Car is getting 2 years now. Since there is no obvious Japanese car for me this time (driven CRV, Cefiro earlier), thinking of exploring Conti for a change (my wife is holding me back from those contis). But, sort of convincing her. My choice is in the order they are appearing in the Poll.

 

Thanks for taking the poll.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

yes i did too there. whats her name grace is it?

 

handling felt pretty numb but didnt test thoroughly. it was the sleepy engine that i didnt like.

 

3L but feels boneless, feelingless. No growl no emotions. Doesnt feel powerful. Doesnt give a kick.

 

Really? I found the XF more urgent than the 523. The handling, comfort and chasis is great. C200 on paper is only 0.1 sec faster. The 523 is rather handsome, high tech and impressive too, so it is just my personal taste and nothing to fault it.

 

Didn't test drive the E class because only the S class and CLS looks appealing enough to me. I must test go test drive the C200, when I accompany my friend to the showroom.

Link to post
Share on other sites

bro when i drove it... it was more like a dead cat. bo lat one. maybe im too used to forced induction on my unstock c-class

 

xf is too heavy too.... felt sluggish similar to a gs300.

 

anyway i dont like the wood trim. i like aluminium

 

is yours the C200 Kompressor (not the newer CGI model) ?

I test drove a C200K before. Somehow I can't really feel the power and the kick of the supercharger.

Was making alot of noise and there's not much ooomph. The supercharger whine is quite loud also.

 

In fact, when my parents was in the test car, they also feel that its not that powerful. They felt that my current Alfa Romeo 159 2.2 was more powerful.

But one thing for sure, the ride is very comfortable. Handling is okie as it's a rwd.

 

Wanted to change from the Alfa 159 to the C200k (not the CGI model), but after the test drive, feel that its not worth the change.

 

ThreadStarter: sorry for the OT. [lipsrsealed]

Link to post
Share on other sites

is yours the C200 Kompressor (not the newer CGI model) ?

I test drove a C200K before. Somehow I can't really feel the power and the kick of the supercharger.

Was making alot of noise and there's not much ooomph. The supercharger whine is quite loud also.

 

In fact, when my parents was in the test car, they also feel that its not that powerful. They felt that my current Alfa Romeo 159 2.2 was more powerful.

But one thing for sure, the ride is very comfortable. Handling is okie as it's a rwd.

 

Wanted to change from the Alfa 159 to the C200k (not the CGI model), but after the test drive, feel that its not worth the change.

 

ThreadStarter: sorry for the OT. [lipsrsealed]

 

haha cuz mine is heavily modded bro [laugh]

Link to post
Share on other sites

and of course i will not go around proclaiming i own a vehicle jus becos i drove one like some of the bros here [cool]

 

becos the fact is that i do not own it

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Really? I found the XF more urgent than the 523. The handling, comfort and chasis is great. C200 on paper is only 0.1 sec faster. The 523 is rather handsome, high tech and impressive too, so it is just my personal taste and nothing to fault it.

 

Didn't test drive the E class because only the S class and CLS looks appealing enough to me. I must test go test drive the C200, when I accompany my friend to the showroom.

 

 

haha i found the 523 more engaging in its drive. The C200 is smaller, in a different class.

 

XF is ok but i think getting abit dated even with FL. new CLS loooks nice

Link to post
Share on other sites

and of course i will not go around proclaiming i own a vehicle jus becos i drove one like some of the bros here [cool]

 

becos the fact is that i do not own it

 

haha ok la. but i very nearly got one that time was on the verge of putting the deposit down till the test drive which was uninspiring unlike the 523. Now im getting an E250 coupe

Edited by Cerano
Link to post
Share on other sites

haha ok la. but i very nearly got one that time was on the verge of putting the deposit down till the test drive which was uninspiring unlike the 523. Now im getting an E250 coupe

 

ok all the best :D

Edited by Ithunk
Link to post
Share on other sites

did u try the new facelift or the prefacelift? 8 speed gearbox v 6 speed....

 

anyway... for its size.... definitely can't compare to a lighter car, wan compare must compare to its comparable like E250, 523, GS300....

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...